By: Savanna Perry, PA-C
Sarah applied to four programs and interviewed at all four, an unusually high conversion rate, finishing with two acceptances including her reach school, Duke. Her most useful contribution is what happened in between: an interview at Elon that she felt she had completely bungled, followed the next day by an invitation from Duke and her best interview yet. She was also accepted at Elon.
Everyone wants to go to Duke, right? Well, Sarah is doing it! Huge thanks to Sarah for being willing to share her experience and tips that she’s picked up while applying to PA school.
I luckily interviewed at all four schools. I received 1 rejection, 2 admittance letters, and am still waiting on the fourth response.
In our experience at The PA Platform, applicants routinely misjudge how their interviews went, and Sarah's cycle is the cleanest illustration we have seen. She walked out of Elon convinced she had ruined her chances — and was accepted there. Your felt sense of an interview is not evidence. Committees are comparing you against a rubric and a pool you cannot see, and a moment of freezing that feels catastrophic from the inside often barely registers. Debrief honestly to improve, then stop relitigating it.
I had a few withdrawals on my transcript.
Sarah's story bank technique is worth building before your first interview: write down every patient experience you have, then map each one to multiple themes — teamwork, conflict, ethical dilemma, stress, failure. One good story can answer four different questions if you know which angle to emphasize.
****INSERT FREE LEAD MAGNET FORM OR HTML BLOCK AND DELETE TEXT BOX*****
I was given a 1 month notice for two of the interviews, a week notice for another, and a two day notice for the last interview! Always be ready! It was a bit tricky getting work off for the last interview. I also found that each school has their own individual vibe. Pay attention to that! Wherever you are most comfortable is likely a good fit.
After my first rejection letter, I read The Physician Assistant School Interview: Essential Strategies to Blow ‘Em Away and Claim Your Seat in Class by Paul Kubin, PA-C. He has great advice for practicing without sounding rehearsed and providing authentic answers. You’re going to stand out if you just tell them who you are and what you have to offer, because you are unique!
Don’t let rejection get you down! Sometimes a school decides not to select you simply because they thought you weren’t a good fit for their program, NOT because you won’t be a great PA.
Use failure constructively! My second interview at Elon went terribly! I froze, my mind went blank, and the examples I gave weren’t representative of what I wanted to say. After feeling like I surely ruined my chances of getting in this cycle, my fiance told me not to worry because my feelings were subjective! I have no true idea of what they thought of me. Also, to use this experience as motivation to knock the next opportunity out of the park. Strangely enough, the following day I received another invite to my reach school, Duke. Due to that awful interview, I was able to pull off my best interview yet at the school of my dreams! A week later, I found out that I was actually accepted to Elon even though I thought I had crashed and burned! You truly never know!
Don’t compare yourself to others! You will be surrounded by super accomplished individuals. Their experiences and merits are great, but in no way diminish YOUR value and what you have to offer! Show them what you got!
Exercise methods to stave off nerves. I realized that I had let my anxiety get the best of me at the Elon interview. At the Duke interview, I practiced deep breathing and thoughts of positive reinforcement when the nerves bubbled up. It worked! I was able to be genuine and thoughtful in every answer I gave. You can prepare all you want, but you ARE going to get questions on which you didn’t premeditate. A clear head is needed to successfully maneuver those questions!
Practice builds confidence! Give yourself plenty of practice, BUT don’t memorize an answer. Make sure that you practice using different verbiage so that you don’t sound robotic. They are looking for originality. They know how to sift out cookie-cutter responses. Take advantage of your work relationships and have a PA or MD give you a mock interview! Practicing answering questions while being nervous is invaluable and something you won’t get when practicing with a friend or spouse.
Write down all of your patient experience stories and brainstorm different ways you can use them. For instance, yada yada yada experience can show teamwork, stress, an ethical dilemma, etc. It’s important to realize what you have in your goody bag and how you can utilize those stories. You can always get more than one lesson out of an experience. That way when they ask you, “Describe a time when you had to rely on teamwork” or “Tell me about a stressful experience and how you dealt with that” you have a multitude of examples ready to go!
– Instagram @saracha821
Undergraduate education: University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill
Overall GPA: 3.67
Science GPA: 3.76
GRE: 309, Analytical Writing 4.0
Total HCE hours: 600
Total PCE hours: 2,754
Shadowing hours: 30
Other volunteer hours: 288
LORs: 3-RN supervisor, Associate Medical Director MD, and a professor
How many times did you apply?: 1
Age: 27
Gender: female
How many programs did you apply to? 4
It varies enormously. Sarah received a month of notice for two interviews, a week for another and just two days for the last, which made getting time off work difficult. Have professional clothing ready, a travel plan sketched out and flexible time-off arrangements before invitations start arriving.
Yes. Sarah listed a few withdrawals as her only red flag and was accepted at both Duke and Elon on her first cycle with a 3.67 overall and 3.76 science GPA. A small number of withdrawals rarely sinks an application, particularly alongside strong grades elsewhere. [VERIFY] Some programs limit how many times a prerequisite may be attempted.
Sarah froze at her Elon interview, felt she had ruined her cycle, and was accepted there anyway. Her fiance’s point was the right one: your assessment is subjective. Note what actually went wrong, adjust for the next one, and do not assume rejection.
At Duke, Sarah used deliberate deep breathing and positive self-talk whenever nerves surfaced, and delivered what she called her best interview. A clear head matters most for the questions you did not anticipate, which you will always get.
No. Sarah recommends practicing with different wording each time so you do not sound robotic, and warns that committees are practiced at spotting cookie-cutter answers. She also suggests doing a mock interview with a PA or MD from work rather than only with friends or family, so you practice while genuinely nervous.
Email [email protected] or use the contact form at The PA Platform to share your acceptance story.
Four applications, four interviews, two acceptances including a reach school — Sarah's cycle went about as well as a first cycle can go, and she still spent a night convinced she had thrown it all away. That gap between how an interview feels and how it scores is the most useful thing in her post. Prepare thoroughly, breathe, and then wait for the letter rather than writing it yourself.
***INSERT HTML SERVICE BLOCK CTA****
Preparing for Interviews for PA School
How to Answer Behavioral Questions at a PA School Interview
What to Do After a Bad PA School Interview
How to Explain Red Flags on Your PA School Application

The Pre-PA Newsletter
Real PA admissions updates, new free resources, this week's podcast, and the one thing to focus on this week of the cycle.
Your email address is safe with us .We never share your information with anyone