Rutgers University PA Program: Katie's Acceptance Story (6 Interviews, 6 Acceptances)

Rutgers University PA Program: Katie's Acceptance Story (6 Interviews, 6 Acceptances)

By: Savanna Perry, PA-C

TL;DR

Katie received six interview invitations from twelve applications, attended all six and was accepted at every one, choosing Rutgers University. Her quantitative GRE sat around the 40th percentile, so she hedged by applying to a mix of GRE-required and GRE-optional programs — and was accepted at both kinds. A C+ in general chemistry became one of her strongest interview answers.

Last Updated: August 3, 2026
Your Pre-PA Bestie Blog - everything you need to know to become a PA in one place.

How many programs did you interview with and what were the outcomes?

6 interview invites (I chose to attend them all), 6 acceptances and I will be attending Rutgers University in the fall.

In this post:

Any red flags on your application?

My math GRE score was below the 50th percentile (around the 40th), which I was nervous about, so I applied to programs that did not require the GRE, and to some others that did. Out of the 4 I have been accepted to, two programs did require the GRE, and two did not… so don’t let a lower GRE score stop you from applying to programs requiring it!

I also had a C+ in general chemistry 1. A few of the interviewers brought it up, and it was a great chance for me to share with them how much I have grown from that experience as a student and also on a personal level. I spoke candidly about the anxiety I experienced attending my first science course in college and how I grew to overcome that anxiety and prove to myself that I had what it takes to succeed. It also was a great opportunity to highlight that I continued on in the series and received A’s in every other science class I took. I think the interviewers appreciated my openness and my response showed them what I have learned and how I have incorporated what I learned then to my school work now.

In Our Experience

In our experience at The PA Platform, hedging your program list against your weakest number is smarter than avoiding programs altogether. Katie's quantitative GRE was around the 40th percentile, so she deliberately built a list mixing GRE-required and GRE-optional programs — and was accepted at both kinds. Screening out programs because of one soft score assumes a filter that often does not exist. Apply to a spread and let the committees decide.

Anything you found surprising about interviews?

How laid back most of them were! I was pleasantly relieved that at 5 of the 6 interviews I attended, I felt that the faculty was truly trying to get to know me. That sounds almost cliche, but it’s true. I can’t stress enough how important it is to take a deep breath the morning of your interview and just let them see the real you. They already know you’d be a great PA student on paper (that’s why you got the interview), but now show them your awesome personality; what makes you, you. It’ll be different than the other people you’re interviewing with, and that’s a good thing. Keep that in mind if you wake up on the morning of interview day and want to just crawl back in bed.


Every Pre-PA Should Know...

Katie turned a C+ in general chemistry into one of her best interview answers by talking honestly about the anxiety behind it and then pointing to A grades in every subsequent science course. Interviewers who raise a weak grade are usually offering you an opening, not laying a trap.


****INSERT FREE LEAD MAGNET FORM OR HTML BLOCK AND DELETE TEXT BOX*****

Were there any helpful resources (books, websites, apps) you used to get through prerequisite courses, the application or interview process?

I used “The Applicants Manual of Physician Assistant Programs 2017” by Mark Volpe and Brittany Hogan religiously (affiliate link). It outlines every accredited program in the US and gives a sort of “quick stats” 1 page overview of each program, categorized by state. It gives stats over things like program pre-reqs, application deadline, contact info for that specific program, unique program characteristics, GRE requirements, and much more. It’s a quick way to quickly recognize and organize all the programs you might be interested in. It even has appendices that will list all of the programs requiring the GRE, and one for those that do not. I can’t stress how helpful it was for me, as before I stumbled upon this on Amazon I was making excel spreadsheets trying to compare programs to one another. This made it so much easier!

Any other advice for pre-PA students?

When I was applying to PA school, I felt like I’d never get to the other side. There always seemed to be another obstacle blocking my application from being complete. It can be a long process, but I am here (finally) on the other side of it and I can promise you that your hard work WILL pay off. Keep pushing toward your goal, and you will end up where you are supposed to be. Don’t let a failed class or a bad GRE score keep you down. Re-take the class, or study for the GRE again (as I had to do), or whatever it is for you that you seem to think is an obstacle toward you obtaining your goal. Because I can promise you that in the end, it IS worth it, and you’ll be so proud of yourself for sticking with it.

Where can we find you?

Instagram: @wenzel_k

Need to Know:

  • Undergraduate education: Bachelor of Science in Public Health, Spanish minor- The Ohio State University

  • Overall GPA: 3.90

  • Science GPA: 3.77

  • GRE: 307 combined. Verbal Reasoning: 157. Quantitative Reasoning: 150 Analytical Writing: 4.5

  • Total HCE hours: 1,200

  • Total PCE hours: ~1,000

  • Shadowing hours: 40

  • Other volunteer hours: 200

  • LORs: 4 total. 1 physician, 1 PA, 1 from undergrad academic adviser, 1 academic (public health) professor.

  • How many times did you apply?: 1

  • Age: 23

  • Gender: Female

  • How many programs did you apply to? 12


FAQ

Should you apply to PA programs that require the GRE if your score is low?

Katie says yes, and her results support it. Her quantitative score was around the 40th percentile, she applied to a mix of GRE-required and GRE-optional programs, and was accepted at both kinds. [VERIFY] Confirm whether each program uses a hard score cutoff, since a minority do.

How do you talk about a bad grade at a PA school interview?

Katie spoke candidly about the anxiety she felt in her first college science course, then highlighted that she continued through the series and earned A’s in every other science class. Name the cause honestly, then point to the evidence that it is resolved.

Is 1,000 hours of patient care experience enough for PA school?

It can be. Katie had roughly 1,000 PCE hours plus 1,200 healthcare hours and went six for six on interviews, supported by a 3.90 GPA. One thousand hours meets the minimum at many programs while sitting below the average admitted applicant. [VERIFY] Confirm Rutgers’ current requirement.

Should you attend every PA school interview you are offered?

Katie chose to attend all six of hers and was accepted at all six. Attending everything maximizes your options but costs significant money and time. It makes most sense when you genuinely would consider every program on your list.

How do you compare PA programs and their requirements?

Katie relied heavily on a published applicant’s manual that summarizes every accredited program on a single page by state, including prerequisites, deadlines and GRE requirements, after initially trying to build her own spreadsheets. The PAEA Program Directory serves a similar purpose. [VERIFY] Always confirm details directly with the program.

How can I be featured in an Accepted! post?

Email [email protected] or use the contact form at The PA Platform to share your acceptance story.

CLOSING

Six interviews, six acceptances. Katie's cycle is the cleanest sweep in this series, and the thing she was most worried about — a quantitative GRE score in the 40th percentile — turned out to matter at none of the programs that required it. Apply to the schools you actually want, including the ones you think will screen you out.

***INSERT HTML SERVICE BLOCK CTA****

You May Also Like:

  • Do You Need the GRE for PA School?

  • How to Explain Red Flags on Your PA School Application

  • Preparing for Interviews for PA School

  • How to Build Your PA School Program List

The Pre-PA Newsletter

Real PA admissions updates, new free resources, this week's podcast, and the one thing to focus on this week of the cycle.

Your email address is safe with us .We never share your information with anyone