By: Savanna Perry, PA-C
A PA residency is not a requirement to work in any specialty, including competitive ones. It can help if you are tied to a specific location, set on a single specialty, or want deeper training, but residencies usually pay less than a regular position. For most new grads, a first job in a supportive learning environment can teach you just as much.
No. A residency is by no means a necessity to land a job in any specialty. The author of this post graduated and had multiple offers across orthopedics, neurosurgery, and endocrinology before accepting a role in general surgery.
In fact, a lot of practices prefer to hire new grads precisely because they can train you to do things their way. As the author puts it, they do not have to teach old dogs new tricks. If someone else trained you first, you might carry habits that clash with how a particular surgeon or physician likes things done.
So if you are worried that skipping a residency closes doors, it does not. Plenty of specialties hire new graduates directly, and the first year on the job is where a huge amount of your real learning happens.
There are real situations where extra training helps. If you are tied to a competitive area and cannot find a job in the specialty you want, a residency can build experience and open a door locally. The author met an orthopedics PA resident who chose that path for exactly that reason: she could not find an ortho job in her location otherwise.
A residency also makes sense if you know with certainty that you want to stay in one specialty for the long haul. Taking a year to go deep can make you a stronger, more confident clinician.
That said, more training is never a bad thing on its own, but it is not the only way to get it. The first year out is often described as PA school part two: school prepares you for the boards, and that first job teaches you how to actually be a PA.
As a practicing dermatology PA, I will add that one of the best things about our profession is flexibility. You can move between specialties without going back for more training, and that is a real gift. So if a residency feels right for your goals, great, but do not feel like you have to do one to be taken seriously.
Money matters here. Residencies usually pay less than a regular position. At the 2017 AAPA conference, the author spoke with a general surgery residency offering $75,000, which was better than the $40,000 figure seen in the past but still well below a standard PA salary. [VERIFY]
There are upsides beyond the paycheck: more structured training and the chance to network throughout the program. If you can afford to take less for a year and invest in the extra training, it may sharpen your skills before a regular role.
If you are skipping the residency, the author's advice is to choose a first job that genuinely supports learning. A good supervising physician who explains things, or a practice that rotates new grads through specialties before they see their own patients, can give you that growth without the pay cut. Always weigh the pros and cons for your own situation.
One general surgery PA residency was offering around $75,000 in 2017, noticeably less than a typical staff PA salary. [VERIFY]
Free Application Timeline → https://www.thepaplatform.com/services/free-application-timeline/
Residency after PA school, or straight to work? Two PAs, two answers.
Residency after PA school, or straight to work? Two PAs, two answers.
Jamie and Erin both work in emergency medicine. One of them did a PA residency and one went right into a job, so instead of guessing at the tradeoffs, you get to hear both sides from people who lived them.
Residency means another year or so of lower pay and long hours, but you come out with structured training and a level of confidence that's hard to build on your own in a busy ED. Going straight to work means earning sooner, but you're learning on the fly and how good that experience is depends a lot on the group you land with.
There's no universal right answer here. There's just what fits you, and this conversation should help you figure out which one that is.
What we cover
What a PA residency in emergency medicine actually involves
Jamie and Erin's different paths after graduation
The pay and time tradeoff of doing a residency
Building confidence in a high-acuity setting
What learning on the job looks like without formal training
How to decide which route fits you
Resources
Follow The Pre-PA Club: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · All episodes
A PA residency is not required to get hired in any specialty
Many practices like hiring new grads so they can train them their way
Residencies help most if you are location-locked or set on one specialty
Residencies usually pay less than a regular PA position [VERIFY]
Your first year on the job teaches you how to actually be a PA
A supportive first job can provide great learning without a residency
No. You can be hired directly into specialties, including competitive ones, without a residency. Residencies are optional additional training.
Common reasons include being tied to a competitive location, wanting deeper training in one specialty, or feeling more prepared before practicing independently.
They typically pay less than a standard PA position. One general surgery residency was offering about $75,000 in 2017. [VERIFY]
Yes. PAs are trained as generalists, which means you can change specialties without additional formal training, a major advantage of the profession.
Look for a supportive learning environment: a teaching-minded supervising physician or a practice that lets new grads rotate through clinics before taking their own patients.
No. Many practices actually prefer to hire and train new grads themselves, so a residency is not necessary to be competitive.
Whether or not a residency is right for you comes down to your goals, your finances, and how location-flexible you are. Either path can lead to a strong career, so weigh the tradeoffs honestly. If you want help thinking through your post-graduation options, we are happy to talk it through.
Pre-PA Counseling → https://www.thepaplatform.com/services/pre-pa-counseling/
Choosing Your First PA Job
How PAs Switch Specialties
What to Expect Your First Year as a PA
PA Salary and Compensation Basics

The Pre-PA Newsletter
Real PA admissions updates, new free resources, this week's podcast, and the one thing to focus on this week of the cycle.
Your email address is safe with us .We never share your information with anyone